Gamification in Concept and Motion
Summary
The idea of gamification has attracted completely different professionals in varied fields comparable to academia and enterprise. Nevertheless, the entire thought behind gamification stays unclear, and it has raised quite a few controversies and triggered divisions due to the divergent meanings it poses, whereas some consider that its theoretical improvement remains to be not but clear. Regardless of a heated debate relating to its advantages and challenges, there was a really restricted research finished to indicate the idea of gamification in different makes use of completely different from a nonentertainment angle. Additionally, there was no credible analysis finished at the moment, or that’s obtainable to focus on the effectiveness or the deserves and demerits of gamification primarily based on a human to laptop research outlook. As such, this research functions of reviewing the significance and usefulness of gamification from human practitioners and interactive methods. Furthermore, the research will even look into the present theoretical foundations of gamification with the view of evaluating it to different approaches of the identical type comparable to gameful design, alternate actuality video games, amongst others. The outcomes from this overview revealed that there’s a rising pattern of making an attempt to grasp the actual that means of gamification as evidenced by rising efforts to have a factual understanding of the idea primarily based on analysis. Regardless of these efforts, there’s nonetheless not stable analysis that has been carried out to focus on or deliver out the actual that means of gamification. As such, this overview focuses on figuring out how gamification may be improved additional by making certain that consumer expertise is enhanced with the intention of selling consumer expertise by creating distinctive designs.
Introduction
Gamification has seen a big improve previously twenty years with believing that this progress is spurred by the adoption of the commerce by the industrial leisure business. Whereas previously gaming was primarily related to youngsters, at the moment’s gaming even comes with younger adults comparable to individuals inside their thirties. Furthermore, gaming extra got here with males, however latest research present that extra girls at the moment are embracing the thought with an estimated 45% of the gaming inhabitants being girls. Immediately gaming seems to be a comparatively new idea, however this may very well be on account of the truth that it’s being exercised within the digital house in contrast to earlier than the place it’s was practiced in different frequent conventional mediums. As an example, the human tradition has at all times embraced gaming from a really early age solely that it was being practiced in conventional setup. Nevertheless, the latest developments in know-how significantly the digital media has performed a big position in selling gaming into the trendy human tradition. Immediately there’s a rising consensus that gaming has made loads of inroads to develop into part of at the moment’s tradition due to the rising digital media panorama. The popularization of gaming has drawn the eye of execs in numerous fields who now search to discover how gaming may be utilized in different areas different than simply the leisure business. Immediately varied professionals are drawing some helpful ideas from the gaming business with a view of making certain that these concepts are utilized in different areas comparable to schooling, or machine studying.
The aim of this research is to overview different analysis research that spotlight the rising traits within the gaming business with a eager focus being laid within the schooling sector. The primary goal of the research might be to discover the theoretical concepts being superior about gaming to establish if is established idea. Secondly, the research will search to seek out out concerning the current analysis discovering of gaming from completely different analysis disciplines. And at last, this overview will strive to attract a hyperlink between the present analysis findings of gamification and the actual work of the concepts which might be already within the software. The research will conclude with analysis discovering of the way forward for the gaming occupation to determine what the way forward for gamification holds in an period the place digital media has taken heart stage.
Analysis Methodology
On this survey, the foremost problem to find acceptable assets was the various utilization of the expression “gamification,” which produced a spread of false positives that described related however distinct ideas. It’s Very Seemingly that human participant analysis on what’s at present known as gamification perform that predates the coining of this phrase has been ignored. On this case, idea papers embody each conceptual papers that try and outline the gamification for an idea and theoretical papers proposing a proof of their underlying character of gamification.
The idea of gamification may be described as an accumulation of probably acceptable, already presents explanatory fashions from different domains which have to be analyzed regarding gamification. That is consistent with the historic trajectory of the idea work in human-computer interplay: whereas the earliest work began with scientific ideas primarily based on remark and analysis methodology, up to date traits in idea manufacturing contemplate many alternative disciplinary approaches (Rogers, 2012).
Opinions of the abstracts of a complete of 12 papers had been chosen. The expression “gamification” is new and never primarily based as a topic or thesaurus expression; consequently, key phrases ascertained how newspapers had been filtered, and standards had been established to make sure that the papers included for inspection fulfilled the definition established on this paper. This collection of databases is knowledgeable by the multidisciplinary nature of human-computer interplay analysis: all kinds of databases and topic areas was required to catch relevant analysis.
An intensive search utilizing the search question” gamification and reviewing sources of these varieties e-book, educational journal, report, seminar supplies, dissertation, thesis, and dealing paper yielded a mixed whole of 769 outcomes. Given the early state of gamification analysis the tendency on this space and laptop interplay to publish to conferences first, nearly all of supply varieties had been seminar papers, and to some lesser extent journal posts.
Gamification in principle
The expansion of gamification is assumed to have been attributable to a number of converging elements, comparable to cheaper know-how, private knowledge monitoring, eminent successes, and likewise the incidence of the sports activities medium (Deterding, 2012). Because of this, the research suggests the addition of the sport research motion usually, which proceeds to develop a methodically thought of framework of the character, design, and impression of matches, and significantly pertinent to gamification these important facets which make recreation experiences participating and enjoyable. We begin by defining the category and makes use of. In clarifying what is supposed by”gaming,” we assemble a platform for making a relative comprehension of gamification. The research then makes use of this basis and ideas to judge purposes of the interval, to find out whether or not or not gamification is the primary idea, and differentiate the ideas.
One contribution of the paper is to explain the terminology and ideas related to gamification. We begin by defining the overarching class and makes use of. In clarifying what is supposed by “gaming,” we assemble a platform for making a relative understanding of gamification. The gaming enterprise has gained the be aware of teachers, academics, and professionals from many alternative domains. Even so, gamification is not a brand new idea, having roots in promoting endeavors, comparable to factors playing cards and rewards memberships, instructional buildings, most notably scholastic levels, grades, and ranges, and workplace productiveness (Nelson, 2012). The rise of gamification is assumed to have been attributable to a number of converging elements, together with cheaper know-how, private knowledge monitoring, eminent successes, and the prevalence of the gaming medium (Deterding, 2012).
Conceptualizing “gamification.”
Regardless of this numerous panorama of theoretical tendencies and prospects, the authors of those analysis research agree that not all circumstances of gamification may very well be positioned alongside these analysis paths, regardless of an more and more cohesive entire being. Finally, the writers confessed, “gamification” because the accepted time period for a special idea they outline as “utilizing match design parts in non-game contexts” (Deterding et al., 2011). The expertise is referred to by gamification, gameful interplay identifies contexts, instruments and the objects that contribute to gamification expertise, and design that’s gameful refers back to the customized of crafting an encounter.
Additional, recreation parts are arduous to specify; the authors’ makes an attempt to consolidate quantities of abstraction are highlighted in all these analysis research. The authors give attention to the way to categorize methods which might be gameful subjective. The method is is on how philosophical investigations and theoretical discourse are at present contributing elements. In distinction to video games, gamification is perhaps thought of less complicated to outline than it’s to emphasise. Most sources agree that gamification is usually outlined because the utilization of recreation components and mechanics, however no normal exists. However a view of gamification, together with requirements for coaching capabilities, and theoretical foundations, requires additional improvement.
Criticism of gamification
Gamification has been broadly praised by professors and recreation designers who’re educated about gamification methods that completely depends on factors, badges, and leaderboards ( Robertson, 2010). Recreation designer Margaret Robertson says such processes suggest taking the factor that is least essential to video games and representing it due to the core of the expertise(Robertson, 2010). Furthermore, in his thesis, Chang (2012) contends that gamification in its broadest utilization is a techno-utopian dream with an advanced previous that privileges the digital and finally doesn’t and can’t fulfill the guarantees of its proponents.
Gaming scholar Ian Bogost is a fierce critic of gamification. In a single article, Bogost (claims that gamification is exploitativ e,perversive and simplification of video games created by entrepreneurs and enormous enterprise with the intention of straightforward revenue. In one other information, Bogost criticizes the expression for being obscure and thus providing the means the place video games may be decreased to their important parts after which used to offer a simple manner of crafting gameful experiences. He disagrees with Zichermann whom he calls the”Darkish Lord” of the gamification motion significantly regarding his conceptualization of recreation mechanisms (Bogost, 2011). However whereas gamification expressed from promoting and business sectors and his criticism of Zichermann can stand up to scrutiny, it reveals a constricted lens to the gamification’s idea. For instance, when Bogost claims that gamification suggests substituting precise incentives with fanciful ones(Bogost, 2011), he appears to be referring to gamification methods that target extrinsic rewards, to the negligence of gamification methods which had been designed with intrinsic motivation in thoughts. Gamification will not be the unique property of business or any self-discipline. the notion has been used, researched, mentioned, and expanded in sectors outdoors of promoting, from, as we reveal on this paper
Outsiders of recreation design and recreation research take into consideration a extra favorable outlook. A social psychological perspective on gamification is obtainable by Antin (2012), who asserts that the vacant, digital rewards derided by members of their anti-gamification camp aren’t the driving elements behind participation motivation, even when the designers themselves don’t perceive it; as a substitute, social elements like self-efficacy, peer and neighborhood endorsement reward customers and encourage their continued participation. One objective of the work is to analysis whether or not these views maintain by exploring how such disparaged implementations as a result of they’re inside gamification analysis and what analysis reveal concerning the causes behind participation motivation in gamified methods.
Concept Synthesis and Gamification Analysis Software
Whereas foundational underpinnings are considerably assorted, these paper findings recommend an rising consensus in 2 areas about gamification: extrinsic and intrinsic motivation. The frameworks developed by 4 analysis research (Aparicio et al., 2012), Nicholson (2012), Sakamoto et al. (2012), and Blohm & Leimeister (2013) are primarily based on clinically validated and extensively accepted psychological theories of inspiration. This basis proposes that an funding in motivation mandated, or above and past a dependence on extrinsic, motivators. The target behind utilizing a gamified technique is to encourage conduct modification in end-users, whether or not that conduct change includes improved performance, elevated participation, or larger compliance. General, the state of gamification principle asserts that the match components can meet these targets by catering to end-users. In different phrases, a user-centered strategy, characterised by a give attention to the wants of end-users within the design of the system’s values
Findings from our overview of gamification analysis reveal an unlimited vary of curiosity however a taking part in subject that’s restricted. Whereas utilized gamification analysis is positioned throughout some domains, the survey findings recommend it’s largely the area of sustainability communities, crowdsourcing, and schooling, and to a lesser extent well being and wellness. Equally, the restricted assortment of recreation components means that factors, badges, leaderboards are a gamification technique. Maybe restricted and replication creativity in this system, an absence of consolidation amongst areas, and the state of gamification analysis promote.
The present physique of gamification analysis signifies that success could also be improved throughout the board within the occasion methods, particularly motivators’ plans are suggested on end-users’ intrinsic motivators. The problem can be to accommodate particular person variations in what’s intrinsically motivating whereas additionally assembly the targets, necessities, and constraints of the designer (or buyer ). Findings from the survey that’s theoretical recommend that user-centered design methodology might assist elucidate intrinsic motivators for a consumer inhabitants that’s given. There Would possibly Not Be a perfect gamified system or an optimum mixture of recreation components, mechanics, and dynamics which at all times works however fairly, gamified methods might have to be selectively designed given the private make-up of the end-user inhabitants or maybe be constructed flexibly and inclusively, permitting for personalisation and customization, to accommodate human customers
Strategy for Future Analysis
Primarily based on the discovering described on this analysis paper, sure pints are price noting that are more likely to affect future analysis on gamification;
A frequent downside within the empirical research surveyed is their structure. Particularly, most research didn’t conduct statistical analyses, didn’t isolate the gamification impact and non-gamified methods, and likewise had been short-term or one-off. Going ahead, one-off research have to be replicated, comparative and longitudinal designs employed, and meta-comparisons run to attract on generalizable conclusions concerning the worth of gamification to get end-users.
A major problem is a disconnect on gamification between utilized and theoretical work. Work for explaining the potential workings of gamification though helpful, hasn’t been validated about gamification work that was employed. Likewise, work that’s utilized might reference principle however would not discover its validity empirically. We invite researchers to discover the theoretical underpinnings in work. This most likely means the formulation of a gaggle of investigators. On the very least, since our findings confirmed a various array of makes use of and interpretations of theories, we recommend that analysis groups contemplate involving or utilizing the providers of specialists on the speculation they decide to analysis.
Lastly, since gamification in exercise is characterised by making use of a restricted variety of match components, future analysis ought to plan to isolate essentially the most promising recreation parts in particular contexts. It will solely be potential after exploratory work has been finished. Whereas there was some consensus amongst theorists on underpinnings, there was an absence of consensus on proposed gamification-specific frameworks. Additional, to the perfect of the understanding, the proposed frameworks have by no means been researched by way of utilized analysis. Future analysis might decide their applicability and mix these frameworks if wanted.
Conclusion
From the previous, Gamification is an strategy for participation boosting consumer motivation and delight in non-gaming, computer-mediated environment with an early collection of empirical work. Gamification’s thought is progressively gaining focus whereas the time period stays used: a definition of gamification is rising, and preliminary frameworks primarily based on psychological theories, comparable to self-determination idea and intrinsic and extrinsic motivation, have been collectively proposed. A multidisciplinary effort to analysis gamification’s penalties on contributors is nascent, however there is a want for its exploration of a spread of recreation parts throughout contexts layouts, and analyses of a number of trajectories. Blended strategies analysis that employs statistical evaluation and experiences impact sizes for experiences, dynamics and parts are essential to substantiate the optimistic outcomes reported. Likewise, research that make use of controls are wanted to find out what results gamification has past and over different sides and in comparison with different approaches, comparable to a recreation that was absolutely fledged. In methods, few research have investigated the consequences of intrinsic and extrinsic motivators No matter its theoretical grounding in motivation. This work, as does this subject’s state is restricted by the summary nature of the survey filtering process mandatory as a result of inconsistent use of the time period. The summary nature in figuring out whether or not or not a system reveals gamification is forecast to develop into much less so to slender down gamification for a principle concerned persist. Despite the fact that a problem for survey work, the current vitality of gamification as an space of analysis and apply is advantageous to its progress, probably drawing swifter and larger consideration. Solely continued rigorous analysis, playful, sensible explorations, and theoretical deliberations with end-users will disclose Whether or not gamification is right here to remain.
References
Antin, J., 2012. Gamification will not be a grimy phrase. Interactions 19, 14.
Aparicio, A.F., Vela, F.L.G., Sánchez, J.L.G., Montes, J.L.I., 2012. Evaluation and software of gamification. In: Proceedings of the 13th Worldwide Convention on Interacción Persona-Ordenador. Introduced at INTERACCION’12, ACM, Elche, Spain, p. 17
Avedon, E.M., Sutton-Smith, B., 1971. The Examine of Video games. John Wiley, New York, NY.
Azadegan, A., Riedel, J.C.Ok.H., 2012. Critical video games integration in firms: a analysis and software framework. In: Proceedings of the 2012 IEEE 12th Worldwide Convention on Superior Studying Applied sciences. Introduced at ICALT 2012, IEEE, Rome, Italy, pp. 485–487.
Bagley, Ok.S., 2012. Conceptual Mile Markers to Enhance Time-to-value for Exploratory Search Periods (Ph.D.). College of Massachusetts Lowell, Ann Arbor.
Bangor, A., Kortum, P.T., Miller, J.T., 2008. An empirical analysis of the system usability scale. Int. J. Hum.–Comput. Work together. 24, 574–594. http://dx.doi.org/ 10.1080/10447310802205776
Barlet, M.C., Spohn, S.D., 2012. Includification: A Sensible Information to Recreation Accessibility [WWW Document]. Includification. URL: /http://www.includification. com/AbleGamers_Includification.pdfS (accessed 09.10.14).
Berengueres, J., Alsuwairi, F., Zaki, N., Ng, T., 2013. Gamification of a recycle bin with emoticons. In: Kuzuoka, H., Evers, V., Imai, M., Forlizzi, J. (Eds.), Proceedings of the eighth ACM/IEEE Worldwide Convention on Human–Robotic Interplay. Introduced at HRI 2013. IEEE, New York, pp. 83–84
Blohm, I., Leimeister, J.M., 2013. Gamification: Design of IT-based enhancing providers for motivational help and behavioral change. Bus. Inf. Syst. Eng. 5, 275–278. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s12599-Zero13-0273-5.
Bouca, M., 2012. Cellular communication, gamification and ludification. In: Proceedings of the 16th Worldwide Tutorial MindTrek Convention. Introduced at MindTrek 2012. ACM, pp. 295–301
Cramer, H., Rost, M., Holmquist, L.E., 2011. Performing a check-in: rising practices, norms and “conflicts” in location-sharing utilizing foursquare. In: Proceedings of the 13th Worldwide Convention on Human–Pc Interplay with Cellular Gadgets and Providers. Introduced at MobileHCI’11. ACM, pp. 57–66
Denny, P., 2013. The impact of digital achievements on scholar engagement. In: Proceedings of the SIGCHI Convention on Human Components in Computing Techniques. Introduced at CHI13′. ACM, pp. 763–772.
Depura, Ok., Garg, M., 2012. Software of on-line gamification to new rent onboarding. In: Proceedings of the 2012 Third Worldwide Convention on Providers in Rising Markets. IEEE, pp. 153–156
Deterding, S., 2011. Located motivational affordances of recreation components: a conceptual mannequin. In: Gamification: Utilizing Recreation Design Parts in Non-Gaming Contexts, a Workshop at CHI. Introduced at CHI 2011. ACM, Vancouver, BC, pp. 1–four.
Deterding, S., 2012. Gamification: designing for motivation. Interactions 19, 14–17.
Downes-Le Guin, T., Baker, R., Mechling, J., Ruyle, E., 2012. Myths and realities of respondent engagement in on-line surveys. Int. J. Mark. Res. 54, 613–633. http: //dx.doi.org/10.2501/IJMR-54-5-613-633.
Eickhoff, C., Harris, C.G., De Vries, A.P., Srinivasan, P., 2012. High quality by way of circulation and immersion: gamifying crowdsourced relevance assessments. In: Introduced at SIGIR’12. ACM, Portland, OR, pp. 871–880.
Fernandes, J., Duarte, D., Ribeiro, C., Farinha, C., Pereira, J.M., da Silva, M.M., 2012. iThink: a game-based strategy in direction of enhancing collaboration and participation in requirement elicitation. In: DeGloria, A., DeFreitas, S. (Eds.), Proceedings of the 4th Worldwide Convention on Video games and Digital Worlds for Critical Purposes (vs-Video games’12). Introduced at VS-GAMES’12, pp. 66–77.
Fitz-Walter, Z., Tjondronegoro, D., Wyeth, P., 2012. A gamified cell software for participating new college students at college orientation. In: Proceedings of the 24th Annual Convention of the Australian Pc–Human Interplay Particular Group. Introduced at OZCHI’12. ACM, Melbourne, Australia, pp. 138–141.
Foster, J.A., Sheridan, P.Ok., Irish, R., Frost, G.S., 2012. Gamification as a technique for selling deeper investigation in a reverse engineering exercise. In: Proceedings of the 2012 American Society for Engineering Training Convention, pp. AC 2012–AC 5456.
Manna, R., Saha, R., Geetha, G., 2012. Complexity evaluation of image-based CAPTCHA. In: Proceedings of the 2012 Worldwide Convention on Computing Sciences. Introduced at ICCS 2012. IEEE, Phagwara, pp. 88–93.
Mason, A.D., Michalakidis, G., Krause, P.J., 2012. Tiger nation: empowering citizen scientists. In: Proceedings of the 2012 sixth IEEE Worldwide Convention on Digital Ecosystems Applied sciences. Introduced at DEST 2012. IEEE, Campione d’Italia, pp. 1–5. 10.1109/DEST.2012.6227943.
Massung, E., Coyle, D., Cater, Ok., Jay, M., Preist, C., 2013. Utilizing crowdsourcing to help pro-environmental neighborhood activism. In: Proceedings of the 2013 ACM SIGCHI Convention on Human Components in Computing Techniques. Introduced at CHI’13. ACM, Paris, France, pp. 371–380.
McDaniel, R., Lindgren, R., Friskics, J., 2012. Utilizing badges for shaping interactions in on-line studying environments. In: Proceedings of the 2012 IEEE Worldwide Skilled Communication Convention. Introduced at IPCC 2012. IEEE, Orlando, FL, pp. 1–four.
McGonigal, J., 2011. Actuality is Damaged: Why Video games Make Us Higher and How They Can Change the World. Penguin Books, New York, NY.
McNeill, M.D.J., Charles, D.Ok., Burke, J.W., Crosbie, J.H., McDonough, S.M., 2012. Evaluating consumer experiences in rehabilitation video games. J. Help. Technol. 6, 173–181. http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/17549451211261290.
Morneau, R.A., Van Herreweghe, W.G., Little, J.W.H., Lefebvre, D.B., 2012. Vitality firm perspective on digital worlds/Three-D immersive environments. In: Proceedings of SPE Clever Vitality Worldwide 2012. Introduced at SPE Clever Vitality Worldwide 2012, pp. 329–340.
Musthag, M., Raij, A., Ganesan, D., Kumar, S., Shiffman, S., 2011. Exploring microincentive methods for participant compensation in high-burden research. In: Proceedings of the 13th Worldwide Convention on Ubiquitous Computing. Introduced at UbiComp’11. ACM, pp. 435–444.
Nelson, M.J., 2012. Soviet and American precursors to the gamification of labor. In: Proceedings of the 16th Worldwide Tutorial MindTrek Convention. Introduced at MindTrek’12. ACM, pp. 23–26.
Neves Madeira, R., Postolache, O., Correia, N.., 2011. Gaming for remedy in a healthcare good ambient. In: Establishing Ambient Intelligence. Introduced at AMI 2011. Amsterdam, The Netherlands, pp. 224–228. 10.1007/978-Three-642- 31479-7_38.
Nicholson, S., 2012. A user-centered theoretical framework for significant gamification. In: Proceedings of GamesþLearningþSociety eight.Zero.
O’Mara, J., 2012. Course of drama and digital video games as textual content and motion in digital worlds: creating new literacies in class. Res. Drama Educ 17, 517–534. http: //dx.doi.org/10.1080/13569783.2012.727624.
Passos, E.B., Medeiros, D.B., Neto, P.A.S., Clua, E.W.G., 2011. Turning real-world software program improvement right into a recreation. In: Proceedings of SBGames 2011. Introduced at SBGames 2011. Salvador, pp. 260–269.
Prestopnik, N.R., 2013. Design Science in Human–Pc Interplay A Mannequin and Three Examples (Ph.D.). Syracuse College, Ann Arbor.
Robertson, M., 2010. Cannot play, will not play [WWW Document]. Disguise & Search. URL: /http://hideandseek.web/2010/10/06/cant-play-wont-play/S (accessed 10.10.14).
Rogers, Y., 2012. HCI principle: classical, trendy, and up to date. Synth. Lect. Hum.- Centered Inform. 5, 1–129. http://dx.doi.org/10.2200/S00418ED1V01Y201205- HCI014.
Alexandria, VA. Rose, Ok.J., Koenig, M., Wiesbauer, F., 2013. Evaluating success for behavioral change in diabetes through mHealth and gamification: MySugr’s keys to retention and affected person engagement. Diabetes Technol. Ther. 15, A114. http://dx.doi.org/ 10.1089/dia.2012.1221.
Rouse, Ok.E., 2013. Gamification in Science Training: The Relationship of Academic Video games to Motivation and Achievement (Ph.D.). The College of Southern Mississippi, Ann Arbor.
Takahashi, D., 2010. Gamification will get its personal convention [WWW Document]. Enterprise Beat. URL: /http://venturebeat.com/2010/09/30/gamification-getsits-own-conference/S (accessed 10.10.14).
Terlutter, R., Capella, M.L., 2013. The gamification of promoting: evaluation and analysis instructions of in-game promoting, advergames, and promoting in social community video games. J. Advert. 42, 95–112. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/ 00913367.2013.774610.
Thom, J., Millen, D., DiMicco, J., 2012. Eradicating gamification from an enterprise SNS. In: Proceedings of the ACM 2012 Convention on Pc Supported Cooperative Work. Introduced at CSCW’12. ACM, Seattle, WA, pp. 1067–1070.
Von Ahn, L., 2006. Video games with a objective. Pc 39, 92–94. http://dx.doi.org/ 10.1109/MC.2006.196.
Werbach, Ok., Hunter, D., 2011. Critical gamification [WWW Document]. Win Critical Gamification Symp. URL: 〈http://gamifyforthewin.com/〉 (accessed 27.08.13).
Werbach, Ok., Hunter, D., 2012. For the Win: How Recreation Considering Can Revolutionize Your Enterprise. Wharton Digital Press, Philadelphia, PA. Wilson, P., 1973. Situational relevance. Inf. Storage Retr. 9, 457–471. http://dx.doi. org/10.1016/0020-0271(73)90096-X.
Witt, M., Scheiner, C., Robra-Bissantz, S., 2011. Gamification of on-line thought competitions: insights from an explorative case. In: Proceedings of INFORMATIK 2011 – Informatik Schafft Communities, Lecture Notes in Informatics. Introduced at INFORMATIK 2011. Berlin, Germany, p. 192.
Yamakami, T., 2012. From gamenics to servicenics: classes discovered in cell social video games in Japan towards service engineering. In: Proceedings of the 26th IEEE Worldwide Convention on Superior Info Networking and Purposes Workshops. Introduced at WAINA 2012. IEEE, Fukuoka, Japan, pp. 352–356
